| What
Indonesia - Bali is all about ?
In
efforts to understand what Mead might conceivably have
had in mind regarding libido, the authors considered
another possibility. The use of this Western concept
implies a view of the individual as separate from society.
This is less true in Bali where the individual is an
integral part of family, society, and ancestors. They
are bound together in this larger system. If Mead conceived
of libido (the energy-driving instincts of aggression
and sexuality-) as bound up in this system (though she
did not speak of it as such), she might have thought
there was none available for individual expression.
Instead, it would be expressed in ceremonies, ritual,
trance, dance, etc.,, leaving none free for the individual.
Given this novel and somewhat tortuous theoretical excursion,
the authors would still disagree that the individual
lacks libido, free or otherwise. The Balinese express
aggressive and sexual energy in a variety of types of
social interaction. The authors question whether libido
theory is at all appropriate for application to the
Balinese and have not chosen to utilize the theory for
understanding Balinese character.Somehow Bateson and
Mead formed and presented a rather negative image of
the Balinese. This is reflected, for example, by their
interpretations about mothers and wives being witches,
their characterizations of mothers as lacking thoughtfulness
and not cherishing their children, and their representation
of the people as generally having schizoid maladjusted-
personalities, to mention a few. Mead's statement that
all the last-grade children and all the teachers in
Bayung Gede were massacred in the political uprising
in 1965 is another example of careless reporting of
data and negative implications. The statement is a gross
error of fact: no schoolchildren were killed, and only
three of the seven teachers died.
BATESON
and Mead 'assumed that Bali had a cultural base upon
which various intrusive elements have been progressively
grafted over the centuries, and that a more rewarding
approach would be to study this base firs. They stated
that they selected Bayung Gede as the village for their
primary study because it lacked most of the conspicuous
elements of 'intrusive cultures'. They stated that Bayung
Gede was ceremonially bare, even when compared with
other mountain Villages, and that it had a minimum of
the 'over-elaboration of art and ceremonialism which
is such a marked characteristic of Balinese culture.
They assumed that it represented the cultural base of
Bali.
In addition, because they noted that goitre was common
in Bayung Gede, they assumed that thyroid deficiency
was the cause of the entire population being 'markedly
slow in both intellectual response and in speed of bodily
movement. They felt that this factor and the 'schematically
simplified' cultural emphasis enabled them to understand
the base of Balinese culture, which in turn would help
them understand the more complex forms of culture which
they had encountered in the plains villages (i.e., the
non-mountainous areas).
Please
access this web site for more Jakarta, Yogyakarta, Bandung,
Surabaya and all Indonesia Hotels bali lombok yogyakarta
jakartahotels- and Indonesian Holidays Information,
hotels and travel reservation indonesia hotels travel
holidays
|